One of the most prevalent themes that we've been confronted with over the last several weeks is that of anonymity, and all it implies.

First and foremost, our discussions of the forum on the Ellenville Journal's website and our policy toward the anonymous posters who call it home have caused something of a row among those who do choose to leave their names on their comments. Many of our website's regulars are, understandably, upset over our policy regarding our nameless and faceless online friends and foes. After all, what's more frustrating than trying to engage in an important discussion about the issues when your conversation partner hides behind a mask, or is speaking to you through a one-way mirror?

But what is important to remember is the safety anonymity provides to those who seek it. Case in point, ­ the Journal is constantly faced with a conflict in terms of information for our articles. We, too, are forced to contend with anonymous callers offering tips and information, anonymous suspects and victims involved in different issues and altercations, and folks who express their anger and unhappiness with certain members of the community…who they then refuse to name. We've got anonymity coming at us from all sides, and yes, it can be extremely frustrating to an organization whose primary goal is to lift the veil of anonymity and to provide our reading public with information.

However, maintaining that anonymity, keeping an identity secret, can often liberate people to say what's really on their minds, and to offer true insight into the world they see around them. Sure, anonymous posters online feel they have carte blanche to act foolishly, and to say things that would make their own mothers ashamed of them. But it can also allow people to speak freely and openly without fear of retaliation or reprisal from those who may do them harm for revealing the truth or for seeking justice.

Furthermore, let's remember this other important fact: our coverage area may span a relatively large geography, but it is still Small Town, USA. Especially in a small town, information that has been acquired anonymously has validity. Small-town gossip and innuendo are powerful forces that can often counterbalance any attempts at anonymity.

In the end, anonymity, like anything else, has its upsides and its downsides. Even we here at the Journal use anonymity for ourselves when the need arises, though that anonymity is limited, at best. While there may not be a name attached to this piece, you need look no further than our masthead to see the people behind the words. Our own anonymity in this case allows us to put forward ideas and opinions as the newspaper, and not simply as individuals. In this way, anonymity gives us the opportunity to speak out and speak up, and gives us the chance to take a critical eye at what goes on around us…proving that a little anonymity can benefit everyone from time to time.

COMMENTS about this article (24)